Skip to content

Authority, Provenance and Trust — v9

V9 introduces more derived and physical artifacts, so authority boundaries must remain explicit.

Four separate questions

INTEGRITY != AUTHENTICITY != AUTHORITY != FACTUAL CORRECTNESS
  • Integrity: do bytes/logical content match a declared digest?
  • Authenticity: did a particular key sign an object?
  • Authority: is that signer/source recognized for this scope?
  • Factual correctness: is the knowledge actually correct?

No one layer automatically proves the others.

Epistemic provenance

Explains where knowledge came from, what evidence supports it and how it should be interpreted.

Build provenance

Explains how software produced an artifact:

source commitments
transform
configuration
policies
toolchain

A builder does not become an epistemic authority merely by computing an artifact.

Publication/activation provenance

Publishing or activating a State Snapshot can be recorded independently from the state content itself.

Composition

STATE COMPOSITION != AUTHORITY MERGE

This matters in systems such as HospitalOps where commons, practice facts, identity vaults and audit systems deliberately retain separate authority and security domains.